IELTS Writing Task 2: Historic Buildings - Band 7.0 Sample with Full Breakdown
Related guides:
The Prompt
Some people think that governments should spend money on preserving historic buildings. Others believe that money should be used to build new public facilities. Discuss both views and state your opinion.
Band 7.0 Sample Answer
Governments have a responsibility to allocate funds wisely, and there is much debate about whether historic buildings should be preserved or whether new public facilities should be constructed. Both perspectives have merit, but I believe that a balanced approach is necessary.
On one hand, preserving historic buildings is crucial for maintaining cultural heritage. These structures often have significant historical and architectural value, serving as tangible links to our past. For instance, the Great Wall of China attracts millions of tourists each year, contributing substantially to the local economy. Moreover, historic buildings can be repurposed for modern use, such as turning old factories into museums or cultural centers. This approach not only preserves history but also promotes sustainable development. However, the cost of maintaining these buildings can be exorbitant, and funds might be better spent elsewhere.
On the other hand, constructing new public facilities can address contemporary needs more effectively. Rapid urbanization and population growth often necessitate modern infrastructure, such as hospitals, schools, and transportation systems. Investing in these areas can improve the quality of life for current and future generations. For example, building new schools can provide better educational opportunities for children, while modern hospitals can offer advanced medical care. Nevertheless, focusing solely on new construction might lead to the neglect of historic sites, which are irreplaceable cultural assets.
In conclusion, while both preserving historic buildings and building new public facilities have their advantages, a balanced approach is essential. Governments should prioritize the preservation of historic buildings that hold significant cultural value while also investing in necessary modern infrastructure. This way, both the past and the future can be honored and served.
Scoring Breakdown
| Criteria | Band 7.0 | Notes | |---------|---------|-------| | Task Response | The opinion is presented, but the arguments could be more fully extended and supported. | The response addresses the task but lacks deeper development in some areas. | | Coherence and Cohesion | The arguments are logically organized, but there may be some unnecessary repetition or irrelevant content. | The ideas are generally well-connected, but transitions could be smoother. | | Lexical Resource | There is a sufficient range of vocabulary to discuss the topic, but there are some inaccuracies in word choice and collocation. | The vocabulary is adequate but not sophisticated. | | Grammatical Range and Accuracy | There is a mix of simple and complex sentence forms, but errors in grammar and punctuation are present. | The grammar is generally accurate but not error-free.
Vocabulary Highlights
- Preserve (v): to keep something in its original state; e.g., Preserving historic buildings is essential for cultural heritage.
- Allocate (v): to distribute resources or funds; e.g., Governments must allocate funds wisely.
- Heritage (n): the full range of our inherited traditions, monuments, objects, and culture; e.g., Historic buildings are part of our cultural heritage.
- Exorbitant (adj): excessively high; e.g., The cost of maintaining historic buildings can be exorbitant.
- Urbanization (n): the process of developing a town or city; e.g., Rapid urbanization demands modern infrastructure.
- Infrastructure (n): the basic physical and organizational structures needed for the operation of a society; e.g., Investing in infrastructure improves quality of life.
- Repurpose (v): to use something for a new or different purpose; e.g., Old factories can be repurposed as museums.
- Sustainable (adj): able to be maintained at a certain rate or level without depleting natural resources; e.g., Repurposing buildings promotes sustainable development.
- Necessitate (v): to make something necessary as a result or consequence; e.g., Urbanization necessitates modern infrastructure.
- Neglect (v): to fail to care for properly; e.g., Focusing solely on new construction might lead to the neglect of historic sites.
- Irreplaceable (adj): impossible to replace; e.g., Historic sites are irreplaceable cultural assets.
- Contribute (v): to give a part of something to a result or to help to cause something; e.g., The Great Wall of China contributes to the local economy.
- Allocate (v): to distribute resources or funds; e.g., Governments must allocate funds wisely.
- Modernize (v): to make something more modern or up-to-date; e.g., Modernizing hospitals can offer advanced medical care.
- Cultural assets (n): valuable items or properties that are part of a culture's heritage; e.g., Historic buildings are cultural assets.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Lack of Depth: Many students provide a general overview but fail to develop their arguments with specific examples and detailed explanations.
- Grammatical Errors: Common errors include subject-verb agreement, tense consistency, and article usage.
- Inadequate Vocabulary: Using repetitive or basic vocabulary can lower your score. Aim for a wider range of words and phrases.
- Poor Coherence: Ensuring that your ideas flow logically is crucial. Use linking words and phrases to connect your ideas.
- Irrelevant Content: Stay focused on the topic and avoid including unnecessary information that does not support your arguments.
Get Your Own Response Scored by AI on English AIdol
Practice makes perfect. Get your own IELTS Writing Task 2 response scored by AI on English AIdol and receive detailed feedback to help you improve.